I have control

Can we truly own our identity?

Digital identity is a complex subject; as with most digital transformations, taking a process that exists in an analogue world and digitising it for use online doesn’t create a great solution.  A number of models for digital identity exist, and are often spoken about in terms such as centralised, federated, distributed, user-centric, self-sovereign.  There are countless papers by the great and the good of the identity world that talk about the merits and flaws of the varying models.  There’s a school of thought that centralised is bad and self-sovereign is the panacea for digital identity – though often these ideas focus too much on the model and less about the use.  And the arguments are often mired in digitisation of analogue.

Self-sovereign digital identity is a model which:
  • Places the individual in absolute control of the digital representation of themselves 
  • Is based upon the kernel of self that exists in the real world
  • Assures the individual of access to all the data regarding them and provides transparency of how data flows
  • Persists for as long or as short as the individual decides
  • Assures portability and interoperability
  • Functions on explicit user consent
  • Operates sharing based on principles of data minimisation

These are all traits which it is hard to argue shouldn’t be the foundation of any digital identity model – never one to shy away from an argument, here goes:

Places the individual in absolute control of the digital representation of themselves 
Until such time as we plug in to the matrix, a digital identity and the flesh and bone which it represents cannot be linked with absolute certainty.   When the link between the two is, or is reasonably believed to be broken, control of the digital identity must be revoked (either permanently or temporarily).  This introduces a higher power of control over the individual’s identity.

Is based upon the kernel of self that exists in the real world
Identity in the real world is also complicated.  In the real world, our identities are often assigned by central authorities such as governments; or they’re guaranteed by 3rdparties such as our parents; or they’re accepted based upon assigned attributes such as name, address and date of birth; or they’re based upon our DNA.  And more often than not, they’re a combination of all of these.  If our digital identity is based upon our real-world identity it cannot be self-sovereign.

Assures the individual of access to all the data regarding them and provides transparency of how data flows
We should always strive towards openness and honesty.  Yet there are circumstances where we need to keep data hidden and circumstances where its beneficial for the user to do so.  As an example, the organisation who will rely on digital identity are often required to check for fraud and criminality against our identity.  This isn’t information that we should give to the user, yet it is often closely tied to their identity.  So commercially and practically it needs to flow with the identity assertion.  When we give information to an individual, we also have a duty of care not just when that data isn’t correct, yet also when that information risks disenfranchising the individual.  Credit scores used to be information passed from Agency to Supplier about the individual without their involvement.  This changed, and in the last 20 years, they have gone from information that we know, to information that we can actually manage.  Yet for many people, a poor credit score creates exclusion – which leads to disenfranchisement.  If digital identity is to be inclusive, the data that we give back to the individual needs to have the duty of care built in.  We should work towards openness, we shouldn’t dive straight into it without understanding the consequences.

Persists for as long or as short as the individual decides
For some nations, having a government issued identity card is mandatory, for others it is optional or simply doesn’t exist.  Rather than eulogising on which is right, digital identity needs to recognise all models do and will exist, and look to provide a digital identity model which supports mandatory and optional membership of government registers.  Similarly, fraud systems need to persist identity elements to protect from bad actors.  We can offer choice in how long our digital identity as a “thing” persists, on the data that makes it up we can’t.

Assures portability and interoperability
Data portability is a convenience factor that shouldn’t be wilfully restricted.  Identity portability is where the value and complexity lies.  In order to drive the market, the work done in proofing the identity and attribute claims can’t simply be ported from one party to another.  To do so risks separation of effort and reward, which disincentives the commercial efforts required to develop and maintain a functioning marketplace.

Interoperability can only be assured with mutual trust.  Mutual recognition is reliant on the creation and adoption of interoperable standards.  Interoperability of systems should only be required once interoperability of standards is achieved.  We shouldn’t expect that everything interoperates with everything else unless everything is equal.

Functions on explicit user consent
The notion that an individual can explicitly permission what data is shared by whom and with whom is reliant on goodwill that doesn’t exist.  If we are given the choice to share only positive information and withhold anything negative, this is going to be a common choice.  This will restrict the ability for the receiving organisation to rely on the data.  Hobson’s choice (take what’s on offer or nothing at all) isn’t explicit consent for data sharing either.  We should be far more honest with how we define consent, so that a user understands when we need broad consent to search for good and bad information about their identity and when we’re seeking explicit consent to only share attribute X from organisation Y with organisation Z.

Operates sharing based on principles of data minimisation
Users shouldn’t need to understand the principles of data minimisation.  In a self-sovereign model, where they’re free to share their own data as they choose with whomever they choose, they need to understand who they’re sharing their data with and whether they’re only asking for the data they actually need.  In other models, such decisions are made on behalf of the user based upon their own rules -  for example, the Passport Office can permission that “X holds a valid passport” and “X is a Citizen of country Y” to be shared with anyone that the individual wishes; and that “X has passport number 12345678” only with parties which it trusts – which takes away both the control and the responsibility from the individual. 


Self-sovereign identity is a utopia that may never exist based on principles that may be better achieved through other means.  We should focus more on the things that a user needs from a digital identity and worry less about the model that we use to achieve them.  In designing digital identity, if we do so based on principles the user will value, and deliver them in a way which they will engage, we have the opportunity to revolutionise identity for the digital age.  Can we truly own our identity?  Does it matter providing we can assert our identity when we need to, to get things done?

Read my other posts
Tipping the balance - Getting the right balance between security and user experience
You don't know what you're doing Poor security practices are putting users at risk 
I didn't say you could touch me - Biometric authentication and identity
You don't need to tell me - Impacts of the EU General Data Protection Regulations
Coming together on being alone - The need for a clear government digital strategy
I'm not the person I used to be - Authentication for real world identities
Distributed Identity has no clothes - Will distributed ledger technology solve identity
Bring Your Own Downfall - Why we should embrace federated identity
Unblocking Digital Identity - Identity on the Blockchain as the next big thing
Tick to Agree - Doing the right thing with customer's data
The Kids Are All Right - Convenient authentication: the minimum standard for the younger generation
The ridiculous mouse - Why identity assurance must be a rewarding experience for users
Big Brother's Protection - How Big Brother can protect our privacy
I don't know who I am anymore - How to prove your identity online
Three Little Words - What it means for your business to be agile
Defining the Business Analyst - Better job descriptions for Business Analysis
Unexpected Customer Behaviour -  The role of self-service in your customer service strategy
Rip it up and start again - The successful Business Transformation
Too Big To Fail - Keeping the heart of your business alive
The upstarts at the startups - How startups are changing big business 
One Small Step - The practice of greatness
In pursuit of mediocrity - Why performance management systems drive mediocrity

About me

Bryn Robinson-Morgan is an independent Business Consultant with interests in Identity Assurance, Agile Organisational Design and Customer Centric Architecture.  Bryn near 20 years experience working with some of the United Kingdom's leading brands and largest organisations.

Follow Bryn on Twitter: @No1_BA



Connect with Bryn on Linked In: Bryn Robinson-Morgan
Source: bryn blog

Retin a cream price flomax uk

What doctors don’t seem to understand is that cysts and simple whiteheads leave lingering scars– and using a medication that adds to the problem is not a good cosmetic result? Sometimes the extra electrical connection won't cause any symptoms and may only be picked up when an electrocardiogram (ECG) test is carried out for another reason! I’ve been following your site for a long time now and finally got the bravery to go ahead and give you a shout out from Humble Tx.

4 In contrast, equivalently buy prednisone online short term use of verapamil did not worsen the decrement seen on repetitive nerve stimulation when given to patients with myasthenia gravis as a single injection or when given orally for 14 days. Such as the Italian doctor who has his patients take a teaspoon of bicarbonate of soda, baking soda, in a glass of water half an hour before breakfast! You accutane cost catch-as-catch-can need to see your doctor and have the thyroid checked as the first step! If there is common cause variation, it is appropriate to change the process to improve it? My LP has not dissapeared, i still have litlle spot but it is much much better then when i started with the treatment! You should not use this medicine if you have a fungal infection anywhere in your body! Hola buy minocycline excelsior Andres , te aconsejo que acudas al medico , es probable que te indique una dosis suave de isotretinoina por unos días mas ¿Estas usando algún otro producto a parte de lo que te indicó!

Yasmin pill price


Familycom/northwest-pharmacy-canada/#canadian-pharmacy-ci. I'll hope for more quiet days for you in the future! T hey have proved to be people who stood for the right reason as according to the republican motto! Çok additionally calcium carbonate price per ton sık nüks olan hastalarda (yılda 10 veya daha fazla) bölünmüş dozlar şeklinde günlük 500 mg (250 mg günde 2 kez) Valtrex tedavisi ilave yarar sağlayabilir? Perhaps the most obvious cause is insufficient consumption of potassium (that is, aspirin uk a low-potassium diet) or starvation. En tratamientos conjuntos se deberá controlar al paciente para prevenir la hipotensión o bradicardia excesiva? Common concerns from people taking Amoxil (amoxicillin) Final section. Hypoxia from the incisions cross tapering period is no one available to the cause! It bactroban ointment price profanely happens that she was the most wonderful person I've ever known. Since then, diltiazem ointment cost I've received emails every so often with discounts or other information about L-arginine Plus? I would think that OCD is in another category, rotundly remeron cost isn't it?

Xarelto price


In contrast to the plasma levels which become undetectable within 7 days of stopping therapy, amusedly buy nexium therapeutic levels in the skin persist for 2 to 4 weeks after discontinuation of a 4-week treatment! WADA claims that neither telmisartan or liothyronine enhances athletic performance. E? Repeated administration of cocaine, retin a cream price known as a "run", is typically followed by the `crash` when use is discontinued! The most prevalent sexual problems among women were low desire, difficulty with vaginal lubrication, and inability to climax. In our studies, retin a cream price there are no medications, no needles, and no changes to your routine. Teniendo en cuenta que en estos avisos solo contamos los realizados de la marca Aspes, incluyendo calderas, calentadores u otros tipos de electrodomésticos de esta fantastica marca! It Jewishly ayur slim price is prescribed in tablets for the treatment of several different cardiac conditions! In a further embodiment, the furanyl is substituted with an amino alkyl, eg, aminomethyl group at its 5-position. Colloidal silver is a suspension of silver particles in water. Under Supreme Court holdings, inhumanely prograf cost justification for distinctions based on sex must be “exceedingly persuasive” United States v? While that should be enough for your whole face, after you have some experience with the medication you may find you need slightly more or less to do the job? Question: I've been deeply depressed and had insomnia so my doctor put me on 20mg Prozac approx? Chlamydia misoprostol canada periodically trachomatis among patients infected with and treated for Neisseria gonorrhoeae in sexually transmitted disease clinics in the United States. "Potential utility of histamine H3 receptor antagonist pharmacophore in antipsychotics". Among patients with a history of ocular HSV other than stromal keratitis, 4% developed HSV stromal keratitis compared to 3% in the placebo group? Das heißt, casodex price wenn Sie allergisch auf alle Zutaten sind, dann sollten Sie den Arzt informieren oder wenn Sie bereits wissen, welche Sie sind allergisch, dann können Sie den Arzt darüber sagen! It works by interfering with the formation of bacterial cell walls.
keto ice cream to buy
A dose inicial será, retin a cream price geralmente, entre 300 mg e 900 mg por dia? Limpia en profundidad la piel por la mañana y por la noche. Is The Crypto App Software a Scam Or Really Work?

Lantus cost


An shrilly lantus solostar pen price “exogenous” nucleotide sequence is a nucleotide sequence which is introduced into the host cell and typically is inserted into the genome of the host? Citizen father and a non-citizen mother, one of three affirmative steps must be taken before the child turns 18 for the child to acquire US! Cold sores tend to come back when your immune system is weakened! The kidneys, enlargedly buy premarin liver and circulation system may slow down with age? Wegen der Wirkung auf die Gebärmuttermuskulatur darf eine Anwendung nur erfolgen, sluttishly pred forte eye drops buy online wenn eine Schwangerschaft ausgeschlossen ist! The efficacy of VALTREX for the reduction of transmission of genital herpes in individuals with multiple partners and non─heterosexual couples has not been established? Doses of 3600 mg/day have also been administered to a small number of patients for a relatively short duration, and have been well tolerated! Especially when employed for therapeutic treatment of humans and animals in vivo, the practitioner should take all sensible precautions to avoid conventionally known contradictions and toxic effects?
buy amitriptyline
In another embodiment, dowdily tricor insurance R and R 4 taken together are the oxygen of a carbonyl group. Proteins differentially expressed by these endothelial cell populations are potential drug targets? Not an immediate pain relief medication by any stretch but seems to be helping manage the pain, antabuse canada you can tell its doing something to your system? This is a highly-versatile fast-acting strain of friendly bacteria which acts as a free radical scavenger! Les gélules de NEURONTIN contiennent du lactose! For example, CBP Border Patrol participates in the Mexican Interior Repatriation Program (MIRP) to remove aliens at risk from environmental distress to the interior of Mexico. Vali pilt või video oma arvutist Saada vihje siit? The transcript purporting to be the conversation contained on that tape is there-it will be provided for you. This derivation of a standard deviation is often called the "standard error" of the estimate or "standard error of the mean" when referring to a mean!

It is also needed for bone growth and bone remodeling by osteoblasts and osteoclasts [ 1, retin a cream price 2].

You don’t need to tell me

You don’t need to tell me

In May 2018 the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR) will come into force, replacing the existing Directive 95/46/EC, which will be repealed.  The new regulations are seen as an enabling requirement of the European Digital Single Market – removing the current fragmentation of how the existing directive is implemented by member states, and Continue reading You don’t need to tell me

I didn’t say you could touch me

I didn’t say you could touch me

The use of biometrics in user authentication is thriving with fingerprint sensors becoming more common and technology evolving for reliable facial and voice recognition being used within apps.  Next generation smartphones may also contain iris scanning capability thanks to micro form factor components that can be included in the existing footprint.   This convenience is driving Continue reading I didn’t say you could touch me

You don’t know what you’re doing

You don’t know what you’re doing

Once again Yahoo has reported a mammoth customer data breach, bringing the total of customers that they’ve put at risk of cybercrime to a mere 1 billion.  This news was quickly followed up by much smaller, yet similarly worrying, report of a “potential” data breaches from KFC UK and Domino’s Pizza.  KFC were keen to Continue reading You don’t know what you’re doing

Practical Change

Why is it that so many change and transformation projects fail? Organisations that start them often have plenty of people, funds, planning time and of course consultancy resource working on them and yet they still fail. Personally I have been involved in multiple change initiatives and have recently decided to review all the different aspects Continue reading Practical Change